02:05
So, the first one comes from Miguel all the way from Miami. And Miguel writes, “Betsy, I love your podcast, and I feel ridiculous even writing this, but my kitchen island is driving me absolutely crazy. No matter what I do, it never looks right. When I leave it empty, the
02:23
kitchen feels cold and unfinished and slightly staged in a bad way. But the moment I start adding things, it instantly turns into cluttered chaos. I’ve tried bowls, trays, cookbooks, flowers, decorative objects, practical objects, you name it. Somehow it always
02:40
looks either too sparse or like I just dumped groceries there 5 minutes ago. I love those beautifully styled islands you see in magazines where everything looks effortless, balanced, and intentional, but I cannot crack the code. Is there a general formula or
02:55
styling philosophy you recommend for kitchen islands? How do you decide what belongs there visually? What just becomes noise? Okay, I have a lot of experience with this. In my past kitchen, it was a galley kitchen. It was so small, so tight, there was definitely
03:13
no room for an island. My previous kitchen had a little more space and we did have like an island that we bought at IKEA, but we pushed it against the wall and um pretty much just use it as a butcher block surface, but not really an island in the middle of the kitchen.
03:29
So, I didn’t have too much to say, but this kitchen that I have moved to now has a huge island. I mean, I think it’s like maybe 16 ft long, maybe 42 in wide. It’s big. There’s so much real estate. I was like, “Oh, wow.” When I saw this house, going from never having a true island to
03:55
having the biggest island I’ve ever seen in my life was um to say the least, intimidating. And first of all, you would be so surprised at how quickly I could fill that thing up. Yes, there’s a sink on one side which requires soap and towels and so that’s, you know, by its nature a
04:14
little bit packed. And then there are, you know, the other sides that have fruit and cookbooks and whatever. But I do have lots of thoughts and feelings, especially because I’ve been dealing with this in my own life. And I will say that my 16ft island typically becomes
04:32
cluttered chaos. If you can even believe it. I can’t even imagine. My first rule of thumb is that on an island, you should only have things that are functional that you’re using in the kitchen. I don’t think it’s a great place for display. Now, the reason I
04:51
don’t think it’s a great place for display is because I am actively using it as a cooking surface all the time, every day. At most I’ll put like a large vase with flowers, but you also have the beautiful pendants hanging down. And so you don’t need to gild the lily. There’s
05:10
already sort of these beautiful decorative elements above it. And I imagine your island probably has pendants as well. All right, so I’ve got the flowers and that’s about as decorative as I get because I do love to have a catchall tray. Now on this
05:25
catchall tray, and it’s a large tray. I think it’s like 14 by8 from West Elm. I have a lazy Susan on there with my oils, with my spices, with my salt and pepper. So, while I’m cooking, I can just rotate it and instantly reach and get what I want rather than going over by the stove
05:43
where I also keep some spices, the oils, etc. Then I have my countertop herb garden. So, I’m growing fresh basil, fresh cilantro. I have skylights above it, so they’re getting lots of natural light and thriving on the island. And that way, I can just grab some fresh
05:60
herbs and put them right into whenever I’m cooking. I have a cash po that has pencils, some kitchen scissors. I mean, these are things that I absolutely must have. Well, I mean, not absolutely must, whatever, but that I’m regularly using at my little command center while I’m
06:18
cooking. And all of that goes on a tray. And if ever something else crazy pops up, I put it on the tray because it kind of wrangles all this randomness. Now, the other thing I keep on my island is I have a cookbook stand. And I don’t actually use cookbooks, but I do use
06:37
cardboard recipes from the box meals that I create, or I’ll pull something up on an iPad and then use it to hold the iPad. So, I’m regularly using my cookbook stand, and that’s really cute. and interesting as well. And then I have paper towels on a roll because when I’m
06:56
cooking, I love to wipe up my surface or when I’m washing my hands, I love to grab a quick paper towel, even though I also have a holder for fabric towels. As you can hear, my 16 ft island filled up pretty quick. Um, and then there’s some stools on one side and inevitably my
07:16
kids are leaving some homework or a little bit of a folder or something like that. There’s always something going on. So, I try and keep it tidy. But the